Is dopamine addiction real, and does a dopamine detox work?
While making things with agents, the pleasure I got from playing games faded. I looked at what dopamine actually does and how accurate the phrases "dopamine addiction" and "dopamine detox" are.
In short
- Dopamine is not the pleasure chemical. It carries the gap between what you expected and what you got, and the wanting of something, more than the reward itself.
- Rewards with an uncertain outcome pull people in. Typing to an AI and getting a different result each time resembles that, but I could not find a study that measures it.
- A dopamine detox does not lower dopamine. A break may help, but the reason is not dopamine.
This month I noticed something: the pleasure I get from consumption-based things like playing games has dropped a lot. Making things with agents, posting on social media, then making again. Somewhere inside that loop I seem to have lost the ability to set aside time for myself.
The first two phrases that came up online about this were dopamine addiction and dopamine detox. I had heard both many times, and I didn't know how accurate either was. I sat down and looked.
What dopamine is and what it does
We usually hear dopamine called the "happiness" or "pleasure chemical." Research says something else.
In the experiments Wolfram Schultz began with monkeys, dopamine neurons respond less to the reward itself than to the gap between what was expected and what arrived. If the reward is better than expected they fire, if it is exactly as expected they stay quiet, if it is worse than expected they go silent. This is called the reward prediction error.1 So dopamine is a kind of surprise signal.
Kent Berridge and Terry Robinson go a step further. In their experiments with rats, even when dopamine in the relevant brain regions was almost completely depleted, the animals reacted to sweetness with the same pleasure. In their view dopamine drives not liking something but wanting it.2 Wanting and liking work separately in the brain.
This distinction settled somewhere in me. The pull I feel while making things looks more like wanting than liking. I want to see the next result, and when it is done, the one after.
Why an uncertain outcome pulls you in
Here another finding comes in. Luke Clark and colleagues studied "near-miss" losses in a game resembling a slot machine, meaning the moments when you come very close to the big prize and lose. Participants found these moments less pleasant, but their wish to keep playing grew. Win-related regions of the brain were active too. On top of that, the effect appeared only when the person made the choice themselves.3
When I type something to an AI there is a similar loop. A different result comes each time. Sometimes it's exactly what I wanted, sometimes it comes close but doesn't work. So I try again.
But I have to be honest here: I could not find a study that measures the brain's reward system while people use AI. What I found amounts to surveys and one or two small experiments, and none of them measures dopamine. So this similarity is an analogy, not something proven. I think it is still an analogy worth keeping in mind.
Is dopamine addiction real
In medicine there is no diagnosis called "dopamine addiction." Dopamine plays a role in addiction, but a person becomes addicted to a substance or a behavior. I'll look at which behaviors count for this in the next post.
There is also the sentence I hear often: "the phone damages dopamine receptors." I could not find a study that shows this directly in healthy people. The basis is mostly studies done with drug addicts. Whether smartphone addiction really meets the criteria for addiction is itself debated. Tayana Panova and Xavier Carbonell examined this in 2018 and did not find enough evidence to confirm it.4
Does a dopamine detox work
A dopamine detox, or dopamine fast, rests on the idea that if you stay away from your phone, games and anything stimulating for a while, your dopamine will "reset." At Harvard Health, Peter Grinspoon writes that this idea has to do with neither fasting nor dopamine. Staying away from stimulants does not lower dopamine. He does find short, planned breaks from stimuli reasonable, and adds that this is not a new idea.5
The neuroscientists speaking in The Scientist stand in the same place: a short break does not "reset" the system, and there is no study that directly tests the dopamine detox.6
So if a break works, the reason is not draining dopamine. Maybe attention goes somewhere else, maybe it is just rest.
Where serotonin stands
Serotonin is also described as the "happiness hormone." That too is an incomplete description. In a study with mice, when serotonin neurons in the brain were stimulated, the animals waited longer for a delayed reward.7 So serotonin, at least in these experiments, seems to be related to patience.
This finding cannot be carried over to humans as it is. Still, it made me think: there is almost no waiting in my making loop. An idea comes, I build it right away, I see the result right away. A game asks for patience, getting somewhere takes time. Maybe part of what is fading in me is that patience.
These are my own observations, not a diagnosis. If you have long-lasting sleeplessness or can't enjoy anything, that is something to talk about with a professional.